![]() |
Help me... I'm having a hard time figuring out what the following grammar is...help me, please! "I can't tell where my house was." "It's a festival held in the fall." These are example sentences from a JHS textbook I'm trying to dissect. My brain is frazzled... |
Re: Help me... "I can't tell where my house was." This is an embedded question. "It's a festival held in the fall." This is a reduced relative clause. |
Re: Help me... Are those actual grammar points, 'embedded question' and 'reduced relative clause'? Sometimes I feel like I know something and other times I feel like a child... |
Re: Help me... Quote:
Your 'where' question is a little tricky. There's also wh-relative clauses. Which is probably more correct for your example. I didn't hear what you said. He showed me where I should go. |
Re: Help me... So, what about this sentence? Would the bolded part be a reduced relative clause or be classified under gerund? Or, would the correct answer to my question be that there is a gerund inside of a reduced relative clause? "The women wearing chima jeogori are making kimchi." |
Re: Help me... Mesmark, After further research, I found out you were correct that my "where" sentence would be better classified as a relative clause. It's just that 'where' isn't one of the main relative pronouns. Also, I found this out about embedded questions over at ESL GOLD website: "An embedded question is a part of a sentence that would be a question if it were on its own, but is not a question in the context of the sentence." So, applying that meaning to my 'where' sentence, if I stripped everything from the sentence it would read, "where my house was" and that isn't a question, so naturally it would fall into the relative clause category. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction... :) |
Re: Help me... Quote:
Whether it's the present participle or a gerund depends on whether it acts like a verb or adjective (present participle) or acts as a noun (gerund.) |
Re: Help me... Quote:
Then you'd need to dissern whether in the context, that was the question the speaker was asking, or whether the speaker was asking a question at all. What I mean to say is, was it an indirect way of asking a question - - > embedded question Where was my house or information - -> relative clause the place where my house was |
Re: Help me... I think I'm scarily catching on... GEEK ALERT!! I'M UNDERSTANDING!! Man, I used to be so cool... Thanks again, Mesmark! |
Re: Help me... Patrick, I put together a grammar explanation on embedded questions at my site: Embedded Questions | Heads Up English | ESL Lessons Hope the info makes it a bit clearer. |
Re: Help me... Thanks, Hue! That page was very clear. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:53 pm. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2